A Design Assessment Scale
for Elementary Schools
C. Kenneth Tanner
section
2 of 4Section I- DEGREE OF FUNCTIONALITY
Functionality refers to how well the design item complements the learning environment.
1-
Promenade Walkways linking main outside areas, ideally placing major
activity centers at the extremes.
2 - Green Areas - Outside spaces, close to the school building,
where trees, grass or gardens may be seen [but no cars or roads].
3 - Quiet Areas Solitary places where students may go to
pause and refresh themselves in
a quiet setting.
a. Inside Places
b. Outside Places
4 - Play Areas - Special locations where children are given the
opportunity to be together, use their bodies, build muscles, and test new skills. Using
imagination and releasing energy are two important activities seen in these areas.
5 - Campus Plan - Several natural and built structures that may be
connected by walkways (sometimes covered), pathways, and/or promenades that complement the
delivery of the educational program.
6 - Entrance
Area A friendly space connecting the outside world to the inside world.
This age appropriate space should be inviting and highly visible
for students and visitors. It should evoke a welcome feeling.
7 - Private Spaces for Children Social places where a small
group of children may go to be alone (i.e. reading areas, quiet places, reflection
areas, listening areas, etc.).
a. Inside
b. Outside
8 - Instructional Neighborhoods Places [perhaps wing(s) of
the building] that include teacher planning spaces, flex zones (places for
multiple use), small and large group areas, wet areas for science and art, hearth
areas, and restrooms. The hearth area is a place used for reading and quiet time.
a. Teacher planning areas
b. Flex zones
c. Small group areas
d. Large group areas
e.Wet areas for science
f. Wet areas for art
g. Hearth areas
9 - Outdoor Rooms - Defined outdoor learning environments - enough
like a classroom, but with the added beauties of nature.
10 - Circulation Patterns - Indoor spaces for circulation should
be broad and well-lit allowing for freedom of movement.
a. Within learning environments
b. Among learning environments
11 - Hallways Passageways, allowing students
personal space when moving within the school. [Ample spaces non-crowded]
12 - Reference - Main building has an obvious point of reference
among the schools buildings. It is a focal point where paths and buildings connect.
This design feature heightens the sense of community. It stimulates students
imagination.
13 - Building on Students Scale - A place designed and built
to the scale of children (e.g. Door handles or handrails low enough for children to reach
to accommodate their heights.)
a. Light switches
b. Seats fit children
c. Door handles
d. Hand rails
e. Shortened steps
f. Water fountains
g. Views (doors/windows that allow the student to easily see the
outside)
14 - Administration Centralized - Administrative offices are
grouped together in a centralized area allowing for connection and convenience. If there
are schools within a school or a campus plan, the person in charge should be
readily accessible (at least for the safety of the children).
15 - Acoustics - Control of internal and external noises levels.
16 -Windows Spaces bringing natural light into the learning
environment. Windows may have some form of glare control, but should be in use
(when glare is not a problem), and be without painted obstructions and other
devices that restrict views. Windows should invite the outdoors inside.
a. Views overlooking life
b. Unrestricted views (when glare is not a problem)
c. Adequacy of natural light (includes skylights and borrowed
light natural, reflected light)
17 - Intimacy Gradients - A sequence from larger to smaller -
public to private spaces, giving the effect of drawing people into the area. These are
usually found in main entrances, but may be used through out the learning environment.
18 - Technology for Students - Spaces with computers, compact
disks, programs, learning packages, Internet connections, television, and video.
a. Computers are placed within the learning environment in a
manner that complements teaching
and learning. Computers appear as an
integral part of the curriculum.
b. Computer laboratories are not arranged in a rigid,
institutionalized, manner.
c. The teacher can easily view all computer screens from one
location.
19 -Technology for Teachers Computers (including laptops),
multimedia and Internet connections are easily accessible. Teachers have access to
technology (outside the media center) for use in research and planning lessons.
20 - Pathways - Clearly defined areas that allow freedom of
movement among structures. These play a vital role in the way people interact with
buildings. Pathways may also connect buildings to one another so that a person can walk
under the cover of arcades.
21 - Public Areas Spaces fostering a sense of community
(unity and belonging) that offer inviting and comfortable settings, including ample
lighting.
a. Auditorium
b. Amphitheater
c. Media center
d. Commons (place for casual student meeting)
e. Dining room
22 - Context - The school and grounds are compatible with the
surroundings and sufficient to facilitate the curriculum and programs.
23 - Harmony - The school is "in harmony with nature."
It blends with the surroundings and brings nature into the learning environments.
24 - Comfort - Classrooms create a stress-free atmosphere.
25 - Excitement - Classrooms create an atmosphere of excitement
for learning.
26 - Learning Zones
a. Variety of indoor spaces developed to meet individual learning
styles.
b. Variety of outdoor areas developed to meet individual learning
styles.
27 - Climate Control - A system designed to maintain a comfortable
temperature in the classroom learning environment.
28 - Intimacy - Spaces suitable for small children to reflect.
29 - Classrooms - Exterior doors lead to a courtyard or well
planned outdoor learning areas.
30 - Communications
a. Phones within classrooms
b. Two way intercom system
c. Phones in teachers workrooms
d. Fax machines in teachers workrooms
31 -Workrooms - Workrooms are near classrooms.
32 - Classroom Walls - Walls are conducive for displaying
students work
33 - Hallways - Hallways are favorable for displaying
student work
34 - Roof system A leaking roof can disrupt student
learning.
|